The Switcheroo
Many books, movies, and even songs have twist endings, but a few have the unique ability to be almost a completely different experience upon going through it a second time through. In the publication of my short story “Evicted” in June 2021, I tried to write a story which is different the second time you read it. This is what I call a “switcheroo.”
There’s a subtle difference between a tale with a twist at the end and a tale worth reading or watching a second time. The Twilight Zone, a well-known series, was known for its twists in such episodes as “To Serve Man” or “The Monsters are Due on Maple Street.” In the lesser-known episode named “Spur of the Moment,” a young woman is frightened to death by an older woman who screeches at her and chases her on horseback. This episode too has a twist if you can remember it. When you finish the episode, it begs for a repeat viewing.
Not everyone loves switcheroos. The late, great Roger Ebert said “A lot of recent films seem unsatisfied unless they can add final scenes that redefine the reality of everything that has gone before; call it the Kaizer Soze syndrome.” (Referring to The Usual Suspects, on this list). His definition is as good as any, but I disagree with him in spirit. If a writer or director can do this well, it makes for an entertaining reading or viewing experience.
If you liked the idea of watching or reading a different version the second time around, here’s a list of movies and books that do just that.
- The Other, a novel by Thomas Tryon. A horror novel about identical twin boys, on the cusp of their teen years. The boys are completely different in temperament. One of them turns their farm home upside down. Hailed in its day next to Rosemary’s Baby and The Exorcist, The Other has faded from most of the collective’s consciousness (e.g. I had to search on “The Other Tryon” to get it to show in Amazon), yet it remains a solid switcheroo.
- The Sixth Sense, a film directed and written by M. Night Shyamalan – No list of switcheroos would be complete without M. Night Shyamalan’s masterpiece. If you haven’t seen it, then watch it immediately. If you have, then you know how good it is. Shyamalan’s other movies contain switcheroos as well, notably The Village.
- Memento, a film by Christopher Nolan – Most people moan how movies “aren’t made the way they used to be.” I suspect people will be complaining about this in the future about Christopher Nolan’s films. We’re fortunate to have such a visionary director in our age. This film, an early example of his skill and one of his best, is engrossing to watch. A movie that moves backward through its events through a clever use of a memory lapse until the viewer arrives at the end of the film. When you reach the “beginning at the end,” you understand just what you were watching for two hours.
- Magpie Murders, a novel by Anthony Horrowitz – Check out Andrew Horriwitz’s fantastic murder mystery with two plots happening simultaneously. A fascinating piece of razzle-dazzle which has a cozy mystery unfold at the same time as a contemporary mystery in the real world of the author. This novel is brilliantly staged. Inspired from Agatha Christie’s novels, Horowitz proves he can channel just about any mystery writer (having done Doyle and Fleming previously).
- Crooked House, a novel by Agatha Christie – Who can choose among Christie’s books? Most are straight-forward mysteries with a reveal at the end that is surprising but may not want to get you to read it again (e.g. The ABC Murders). There are others that may entice you for a second read. Among her most famous are And Then There Were None. Murder on the Orient Express, and Crookied House. I chose Crooked House as it’s the least known of the three, but when you get to the end and you say “what just happened?” you know you’ve just read a great switcheroo.
- The Usual Suspects, a film by Bryan Singer – Often people think these plots are only for fantasy, science fiction, or horror. Mystery is also fertile ground for switcheroos. The movie revolves around the mysterious figure of Kaiser Soze. The Usual Suspects has such an interesting reveal at the end that I dare you not to rewatch certain parts over. You may not like Kevin Spacey’s personal life, but he delivers one of his finest performances in this film.
- The Prestige, a film by Christopher Nolan. Another Nolan. In my mind, this is two different experiences the second time around. The movie splits its time between two magicians—both with secrets—that when revealed at the end, make you look at the same scene in a totally different light. The conversations and what they really mean are wildly different the second time through even though it’s exactly the same dialogue. This is my favorite personal switcheroo and cemented me as a Nolan fan for the rest of his career.
Runners-Up: Whatever Happened to Baby Jane, The Village (Shylamalan again), Inception (Nolan again), Vertigo (Hitchcock’s switcheroo), TV’s The Prisoner, and Shutter Island.











